Leadership is fundamentally about guiding others toward a common vision and motivating them to take action. Thus, effective communication lies at the core of true leadership. However, many leaders believe they are conveying their messages clearly when, in reality, they are not. This issue, often referred to by psychologists as the “Illusion of Transparency” or impacted by the “Curse of Knowledge,” causes us to overestimate how well our intentions and instructions are perceived by others. Throughout my years in executive coaching, I have observed many executives and managers grappling with the disconnect between what they mean to communicate and what their teams actually comprehend. Recognizing this gap, understanding its origins, and learning how to bridge it is essential for any leader aiming to foster a culture of clarity and high performance.
The Psychology Behind the Illusion
One of the primary psychological underpinnings of this illusion is known as the Curse of Knowledge. This concept suggests that once we know something whether it’s a strategic detail, organizational nuance, or technical concept we find it extremely difficult to imagine what it is like not to know it. As a result, leaders unintentionally speak from a place of assumed familiarity. They assume that their audience has the same context, background knowledge, and vocabulary that they do. Research published in the journal Psychological Science (Birch & Bloom, 2007) indicates that as people gain expertise in a subject, their ability to accurately gauge someone else’s level of understanding diminishes.
Additionally, the Illusion of Transparency compounds this problem. This effect occurs when we falsely believe our inner thoughts, intentions, or emotions are more evident to others than they truly are. Leaders who experience this illusion might make a quick statement in a meeting and assume everyone fully grasps the direction and details; after all, is is crystal clear in the leaders head. But the reality is that each person in the room interprets that statement through their own lens, influenced by their role, experiences, and knowledge base.
This combination of the Curse of Knowledge and the Illusion of Transparency creates a powerful trap for leaders. By not acknowledging these biases, executives can unintentionally bring confusion, lack of engagement, and missed objectives. The solution lies not in communicating more, but in communicating better with intentionality, empathy, and checks for comprehension.
Impact on Organizational Effectiveness
Effective communication from leadership is crucial for alignment, productivity, and morale. According to a 2017 survey by Gallup, only 13% of employees strongly agree that their organization’s leadership communicates effectively. This disconnect has repercussions: projects miss deadlines, strategic goals remain misunderstood, and employees disengage because they are unsure where the organization is headed. A lack of clarity from leadership can create a cascade effect of confusion, as managers pass along vague directives to their direct reports, further muddying the water.
Clarity in communication is especially critical during times of organizational change. A McKinsey & Company report found that roughly 70% of change initiatives fail to achieve their objectives, with poor communication cited as one of the primary culprits. If the leaders vision for the change is not articulated clearly, or if employees are not given opportunities to ask questions and voice concerns the entire initiative is at risk. From mergers and acquisitions to implementing new software systems, the clarity of leaderships communication can mean the difference between chaotic transitions and smooth, successful adoption.
My executive coaching clients often share stories of how quickly miscommunication can become the norm if not addressed early. In one instance, a CEO launched a major strategic shift across multiple departments but neglected to provide a clear rationale and roadmap. Managers, uncertain about specifics, resorted to rumor or assumptions. Productivity plummeted, anxiety rose, and the CEO eventually had to conduct a round of clarifying meetings months too late to prevent cultural damage.
Relevance to Today’s Leaders
In an era of remote and hybrid work environments, clarity in leadership communication is more important and more challenging than ever. With teams scattered across multiple time zones, messages are easily distorted or lost in translation via digital platforms like email, Teams or Zoom. Leaders may believe they have provided a comprehensive explanation of a new policy or initiative, yet employees on the receiving end might see only fragmented instructions.
Additionally, the pace of business has accelerated dramatically. Rapid technological advances mean that strategies and product lines can shift within months, if not weeks. Leaders must communicate constant pivots to teams while maintaining morale and direction. In this fast-paced climate, leaders cannot afford to rest on assumptions about shared understanding. They must adopt a proactive, persistent approach to ensure their messages are well understood.
Also, the diversity of today’s workplaces highlights the need for adapted communication strategies. Different cultural backgrounds and varied communication styles can lead to misunderstandings if leaders do not pay close attention to clarity. Research in the Harvard Business Review (2019) found that leaders who adopt inclusive communication practices such as inviting questions, using multiple communication channels, and offering tailored explanations foster higher levels of engagement and trust among diverse teams.
Strategies to Overcome the Illusion
- Invite Feedback and Check for Understanding
One of the simplest yet most effective ways to ensure your message is received as intended is to ask for paraphrasing. Encourage team members to repeat back what they understood or outline what they believe the next steps are. This might feel awkward initially, but it provides a real time test of clarity. In my own coaching practice, I suggest leaders schedule short “understanding checks” following major announcements or strategic updates to confirm that alignment is truly in place.
- Use Multiple Communication Channels
Different people absorb information best in different ways some prefer written memos, others prefer verbal explanations, and still others need visuals. By distributing important messages across multiple channels (e.g., email, video calls, one-on-one meetings, and written summaries), leaders reinforce key points and minimize the chance of misunderstandings. According to a study in the Journal of Business and Technical Communication (2017), multimodal communication significantly increases employee retention of complex information.
- Simplify and Structure Your Message
The more complex the information, the more critical it is to break it down into digestible parts. Avoid jargon and acronyms unless you are certain everyone shares the same definitions. Use bullet points or numbered lists to highlight key steps or responsibilities. Emphasize the “why” behind decisions. Research by Atwater and Waldman (2008) indicates that when employees understand the reasoning behind a change or directive, they are far more likely to follow through with genuine buy in.
- Provide Contextual Bridges
If you reference a past decision or rely on specialized knowledge, provide a brief refresher to ensure no one is left behind. Leaders often rush to the “end result,” forgetting that not everyone traveled the same journey. Building context bridges can mean including a quick recap or background summary: “Remember last quarters data analysis showed a 20% decline in conversions, so we are making these changes to improve the user experience.”
- Promote a Culture of Open Dialogue
Encourage questions, feedback, and even pushback. Let people know there is no penalty for admitting they do not understand something. By fostering an environment where clarity is valued over saving face, you encourage your team to speak up. In doing so, you diminish the illusion that everyone is on the same page by default. A 2021 Deloitte survey on organizational culture found that teams perform best when leaders actively solicit and reward open communication.
The Executive Coach’s Perspective
Overcoming the illusion of clarity is not just a tactical exercise; it’s an ongoing commitment to personal growth and organizational health. As an executive coach, I often work with leaders who initially struggle to see why their teams “just don’t get it.” The turning point usually arrives when they recognize their own assumptions and blind spots. We work together to develop habits of deliberate communication, structuring messages, checking for understanding, and creating transparent feedback loops.
Ultimately, clear communication stems from a mindset of curiosity and empathy. Leaders must consistently ask themselves: “How can I ensure my team really understands this the way I do?” And then they have to be courageous enough to test that assumption. If clarity is not there, the leader must have the humility to revise and restate, rather than blame the listener.
Conclusion
The illusion of clarity is a subtle yet potent obstacle for leaders at all levels. From the intricacies of human psychology to the practical realities of global, fast paced business, many factors conspire to make leaders believe their messages are clearer than they are. Yet awareness is the first step. By consciously applying strategies such as multiple communication channels, contextual bridging, and proactive comprehension checks, leaders can bridge the gap between their intentions and their teams understanding.
In today’s complex and shifting environment, clarity of communication is more than a “nice to have”—it’s an essential leadership skill that directly impacts strategic outcomes, employee engagement, and long-term organizational success. Whether you are a seasoned executive or an emerging leader, remember: the responsibility for clarity always rests on the communicator, not the listener. Embrace that responsibility, and you will find your team not only hears your words but genuinely aligns with your vision.
Paul Sheesley is one of a select group of executive coaches worldwide who combines clinical psychology, emotional intelligence, and leadership coaching to create a comprehensive model for leadership transformation. Find more of his insights and learn about his coaching services at Executive Performance Coaching.
Looking for more suggestions on how to improve your communication skills to a level you never thought possible? Check out our Presentation Transformation online course!
